
Canada counts its public servants. It tracks how many are women, how many belong to visible minority groups, how many identify as Indigenous or as persons with disabilities. It publishes these numbers annually. It compares them to workforce availability estimates. It reports progress.
What it does not do nearly well enough is tell us what happens to those employees once they are inside.
This is the disaggregated data problem — and it sits at the heart of why DEI accountability in Canada’s public sector remains incomplete. Aggregated diversity statistics tell us who is present in an institution. They do not tell us who is thriving, who is stalled, who is leaving and why. They create a picture of representation that can look like progress while masking persistent inequity beneath the surface.
Consider what the available data already suggests. The Employment Equity Act Annual Report shows that members of visible minority groups are represented in the federal public service at rates that meet or exceed workforce availability in several occupational categories. On paper, this looks like success. But representation at entry level does not equal representation in leadership. When you disaggregate by occupational group and salary band, a different picture begins to emerge — one where racialized employees are concentrated in lower classification levels and underrepresented in executive ranks.
This pattern has a name in the research literature: the concrete ceiling — a variation on the glass ceiling concept that describes the compounded barriers facing racialized women and immigrants in organizational hierarchies. Unlike the glass ceiling, which implies visibility of what lies above, the concrete ceiling suggests something more impenetrable: barriers that are structural, cultural and largely invisible in aggregated reporting.
What would better data look like? It would mean collecting and publishing workforce outcomes like promotion rates, lateral mobility, attrition and engagement scores — broken down not just by designated group, but by race, national origin, language background and intersection of these with gender. It would mean asking not just who works here, but how their experience of work compares to their peers. It would mean longitudinal tracking that follows employees across their careers rather than capturing a single demographic snapshot each year.
Some of this data exists in scattered form — in public service employee surveys, in exit interview records, in grievance and harassment complaint logs. But it is rarely synthesized, rarely disaggregated to the level that would reveal systemic patterns, and rarely connected back to the DEI commitments institutions have made publicly.
The reluctance to collect and publish this kind of data is itself revealing. Disaggregated outcome data makes accountability concrete. It turns abstract commitments into measurable obligations. It makes it possible to ask — and answer — whether the Federal Employment Equity Act, the Call to Action on Anti-Racism and the various departmental inclusion strategies are actually working for the people they name.
That is precisely why it is uncomfortable. And precisely why it is necessary.
Canada has the infrastructure, the institutional capacity, and the policy mandate to collect this data. What has been missing is the political and organizational will to treat disaggregated outcomes as a non-negotiable component of DEI accountability — not an optional enhancement, but a baseline requirement.
Until we count what actually matters, we will keep celebrating numbers that tell only part of the story.
Next in this series: Data reveals patterns, but it does not capture experience. In my next post, I turn to the lived realities of racialized immigrant employees inside Canadian public institutions and explain why their stories are essential to understanding what the numbers alone cannot show.