
Imagine someone calls for help because a loved one is experiencing a mental health crisis. They might be distressed, overwhelmed or behaving in ways that are difficult to understand.
Before anyone arrives, decisions may already be underway. What is happening? Is anyone in immediate danger? What kind of support is needed and who is best suited to provide it?
These decisions often need to be made quickly, sometimes with limited information, and can influence how a crisis response unfolds.
At the centre of many of these decisions is a familiar concept: risk. But what exactly do we mean when we describe a situation or someone as risky? And how do we determine what constitutes danger in the first place?
What Makes Something Risky?
Risk generally refers to the possibility that something harmful might happen. In mental health crisis response, this can involve concerns about harm to the person experiencing the crisis, responders or others.
Assessing these possibilities is an important part of providing safe and appropriate crisis care. However, making judgments about potential harm is not always straightforward.
Consider someone who is shouting, pacing and visibly distressed. Depending on the circumstances, these behaviours might raise concerns about escalating danger or be understood as expressions of fear, frustration or unmet needs. Understanding what is happening requires considering the broader context, the information available and the circumstances of the person experiencing the crisis.
Research suggests that judgments about risk can also involve interpretation. Even when assessing similar circumstances, people may differ in how they interpret and understand the likelihood of harm or the response they consider appropriate.
This raises an important question: What influences how we recognize and respond to risk?
As I’ve discussed in earlier blog posts, mental illness and psychological distress have historically been associated with dangerousness. These associations can influence public perceptions of mental health crises and raise questions about how broader understandings of danger and safety may inform crisis response.
Risk also plays a role in the policies and procedures that guide decisions about crisis intervention. When someone calls for help, dispatchers must consider the information available, assess potential safety concerns and determine which services are appropriate. Depending on the local crisis response system and circumstances, this might involve a civilian-led crisis team, police, emergency medical services or some combination.
The decision about who responds can involve weighing different safety considerations. For example, police involvement may be considered appropriate when there are concerns about immediate danger. At the same time, research has raised concerns about the potential for police involvement in mental health crises to result in coercion, escalation or the use of force (see my past blog posts). Crisis response decisions can therefore involve several possibilities of harm, each of which may require attention. How these concerns are identified and weighed can influence which responses are considered appropriate.
Rethinking Risk
Risk will always be an important consideration in mental health crisis response. Responders must often make difficult decisions under uncertain circumstances, and concerns about potential harm deserve careful attention.
Still, there is value in examining how we make these judgments.
What information informs our understanding of danger?
Which safety concerns receive the greatest attention?
And how might different approaches to assessing risk shape the support someone receives?
As crisis response systems continue to evolve, questions about risk remain central to how we approach safety and care. In my next blog post, I’ll explore how understandings of risk shape crisis response decisions and what these decisions mean for the safety and well-being of everyone involved.
Photo by Myles Bloomfield on Unsplash