
In my last blog post, I talked about the different dimensions of well-being. This time, I want to come back to pensions but look at them through a different lens: ethics and fairness.
When people talk about an aging population, the conversation usually turns into a numbers game pretty fast. How much will pensions cost? Can our healthcare system handle more older adults? What happens when fewer workers are supporting more retirees? These are real questions worth asking. But there’s another one that doesn’t get nearly as much attention: what does fairness actually look like in old age?
This question matters because people don’t arrive at retirement having lived the same life. Some spent decades in stable, well-paid jobs and accumulated savings. Others spent years caring for kids, a spouse or aging parents. Some worked physically demanding jobs that paid little. Others dealt with illness, disability, unemployment or migration and circumstances that made it harder to save.
If retirement income is based entirely on someone’s job history and earnings, those inequalities just follow people into old age. That’s why I think programs like Old Age Security (OAS) and the Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS) are doing more than just handing out money.
Financial insecurity touches nearly every part of daily life. Imagine constantly doing mental math about whether you can afford groceries, medication, transit, rent or an unexpected bill. That stress doesn’t switch off at the end of the month, but it just becomes part of how you live. A predictable income offers something more than just money: peace of mind. Knowing the money will be in your bank account every month means you can actually plan, buy enough food, pay the bills and worry a little less about tomorrow.
It also opens up choices about how people spend their later years. For someone who spent decades in physically demanding work, a pension might finally mean being able to stop and give their body a break. For someone else, it might mean having the time to care for a partner, help raise grandkids, volunteer or get more involved in their community.
This matters because older adults are sometimes discussed as if they become a burden once they can no longer work, even though they continue to contribute to society in different ways. Caring for family, supporting grandchildren, helping neighbours, volunteering and maintaining social connections all have value, even though they rarely appear in economic calculations.
Canada’s OAS program stands out because it’s not based on how much someone earned over their working life. It’s based mainly on age and years lived in Canada. There’s an ethical idea baked into that: everyone deserves a basic income floor in old age, regardless of their work history and security shouldn’t depend entirely on how much someone participated in the labour market. This is especially important for people whose contributions were less visible economically. Someone who spent years as an unpaid caregiver, for instance, likely didn’t build up the same retirement savings as someone who worked continuously. That doesn’t mean what they did mattered less.
GIS pushes this idea even further. OAS gives everyone a foundation; GIS adds extra support for those with lower incomes. In other words, treating everyone identically isn’t always the same as treating everyone fairly. When people reach old age with very different resources behind them, some need more support just to reach a basic level of security.
There’s also something important in how that support gets delivered. People shouldn’t have to keep proving that they’re struggling or convince someone they deserve help, just to receive it. The process itself can protect people’s dignity or chip away at it. Honestly, that’s where this conversation matters more to me than the pension amount itself.
Photo by Brett Jordan