
Finally. We’ve now arrived at a critical point in the journey of a laterally transferred gene. It has successfully entered a new bacterial cell, delivered by a mobile genetic element. Although this might seem like a triumph in itself, it’s only just the beginning.
But before we get to that, it’s worth remembering that bacterial cells aren’t just happily accepting new genes. They actually defend themselves against incoming foreign DNA. One of the main defense systems is called the restriction-modification system, where the cell chemically tags its own DNA with specific patterns and marks it as ‘self.’ Any incoming DNA that doesn’t have these patterns is flagged as an intruder and gets chopped up (literally) by molecular scissors called restriction enzymes. Another defense system, and one of my favorites: is the CRISPR-Cas adaptive immune system. You’ve probably heard of it in the context of gene editing (it even won a Nobel Prize). Bacteria keep short DNA fragments from past invaders in a region called the CRISPR array. If the same DNA sequence shows up again, the CRISPR system quickly recognizes it as an intruder and targets it for destruction using Cas proteins. You have to admit, this is a pretty brilliant immune strategy!
But let’s say a foreign gene somehow dodges all of these defenses and finds a spot inside the new genome. What are its possible fates? The fate of that gene almost entirely depends on whether it brings something useful to the table. That usefulness can vary depending on where the gene lands in the genome and whether the host cell even wants it around. If the new gene offers a direct benefit, like helping the cell resist antibiotics, use a new food source, or even help it escape predators, then it has a real fighting chance of being kept. In evolutionary terms, this means it increases the organism’s fitness, or its ability to survive and pass on its genes to the next generation. But fitness is context dependent; a gene that’s helpful in one environment might be neutral or even harmful in another. Genes that consistently boost fitness are more likely to be maintained over time and can even become fixed and essential in a population. On the other hand, if the gene does nothing, offers no advantage, or worse, disrupts important processes and wastes energy, then it’s usually purged.
Although we often focus on the exciting success stories of lateral gene transfer, the reality is that many transfer events don’t last. Some studies even suggest that only about 10 to 15% of acquired genes are retained over the long term. So, even though bacteria are constantly acquiring new genetic material through LGT, they’re also constantly getting rid of it.
Gene loss is actually very common in bacterial genomes due to deletional bias, which is a tendency for non-essential DNA to be lost over time. This is particularly pronounced in bacteria due to the pressure for streamlined, efficient genomes. Silencing often occurs before deletion. Sometimes, mutations (changes to the DNA sequence) can inactivate a gene, turning it into what’s called a pseudogene. These are remnants that no longer function but are still visible in the genome, but eventually they also may be deleted. A classic example is Shigella, a pathogenic bacterium with a genome full of pseudogenes that are still functional in its ancestor, Escherichia coli. Many of these genes were likely acquired through LGT but became inactivated as they were no longer beneficial in Shigella‘s lifestyle. Their fate may have been decided by either random mutations, a lack of interaction, or simply, just bad timing.
By interaction, I mean the number and complexity of connections a gene has with other genes and cellular systems. These connections matter, and you might remember the complexity hypothesis from an earlier post. According to this, genes involved in complex, highly interactive cellular processes are less likely to be successfully transferred because they depend on multiple compatible partners. To improve their chances of staying in the new genome, some genes don’t travel alone and arrive as part of a coordinated team called operons, which are essentially clusters of genes that function together. These operons can provide a fully functional pathway or system as soon as they arrive and often include not only the genes themselves, but also their own regulatory elements, making them more autonomous and easier to integrate. This is especially true for metabolic or resistance pathways that must function cohesively from the start.
In the end, not every gene that enters a new bacterial cell gets to stay, but for those that do the consequences can be huge. And this is part of what makes bacterial genomes so fascinating! They’re constantly changing and it’s also one of the many reasons I’m passionate about studying them. They just never seem to settle.
Image created using Imagen3 with the following prompt: “Draw an image of an immigrant gene going through immigration control, focusing on its nervous expression”